Softball

Matt Richwine

Men's Softball Head Coach

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

This Is Not Coaching, This Is Control, Favoritism, And Mistreatment

Date: June 11, 2025

By Parent

1.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

1.0

Tags

"I have a lot to say about Matthew Richwine — and none of it is good. If you love softball, do yourself a favor and don’t play for him. He has a way of draining every ounce of joy from the game, replacing it with control, manipulation, and an environment so toxic it could poison an entire team. The other review you’ve seen? Believe it. Every word is spot-on. Let’s start with one of his most disturbing tactics: the so-called “Leadership Board.” At first glance, it sounds like a development opportunity. In reality, it’s a power play. Richwine hand-selects a few favored players, often not based on talent or leadership but on personal favoritism, and meets with them privately every other week. These meetings are not constructive. They are thinly veiled gossip sessions, where he openly criticizes and ridicules his own players behind their backs. He encourages these handpicked girls to rank, judge, and talk down their teammates, creating a culture of division, paranoia, and elitism. If Richwine doesn’t like you, there’s no hiding from it. You’ll be slandered, excluded, and judged—by your own teammates, all with his encouragement. He has even implemented a twisted rating system where these same players, under his influence, evaluate others' “commitment” to the team. You’re not assessed on effort, integrity, or performance. You’re assessed on whether or not he likes you. You don’t have a voice. He decides. He controls. He manipulates. But perhaps the most indefensible aspect of his coaching is what he chooses to ignore. When a player goes to a coach after enduring numerous physical hits and countless verbal abuse from another teammate, an issue that was ongoing, serious, and deeply harmful, what do you think a coach should do? Nothing according to Richwine. He looked the other way. Why? Because he’s known the abusive player’s family for over ten years. Rather than protecting a vulnerable athlete, rather than stepping up as a coach and a mandatory reporter, he chose to protect his personal relationships. He chose silence. He chose complicity. That alone should disqualify him from any leadership role. It’s not just poor coaching: it’s a betrayal of trust, safety, and basic human decency. Matthew Richwine doesn’t build a team. He builds a hierarchy of favorites and enablers, fueled by intimidation and favoritism. If you want to grow as a player, if you care about respect, accountability, and actual leadership—look elsewhere. You deserve better than this. Every athlete does. And all that is only what I had the energy to type out regarding this man. I’ll let you think about that for a second. "

0

Lacrosse

Dave Webster

Men's Lacrosse Head Coach/ Assitant athletic director

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

The Best Coach In College Lacrosse

Date: June 7, 2025

By Parent

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Direct Creates A Great Team Culture Accessible Cool Intense

"A leader of men. Cares about his players on and off the field. "

0

Women's Volleyball

Jenn McMonagle

Women's Volleyball Head Coach

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

She Made Me Hate The Sport I Used To Love And I Am Quitting Because Of Her.

Date: October 11, 2024

By Other

1.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

1.0

Tags

Intense Poor Communication

"Horrible. Not what she seems. She seems so nice in recruiting but in reality she is crazy and emotional. She makes mistakes feel like the end of the world and she picks favorites. "

0

Men's Tennis

Cole Sutton

Men's Tennis Assistant Coach

Loyola University (Maryland)

NCAA DI • Golden Valley | GVC

Very Calm, Cool And Direct Coach.

Date: October 8, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"Very supportive and calm assistant head coach, very useful for our team."

0

Men's Tennis

Cole Sutton

Men's Tennis Assistant Coach

Loyola University (Maryland)

NCAA DI • Golden Valley | GVC

Organized And Great Communicator!

Date: October 2, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"Cole Sutton seems like a great coach. Passionate about coaching, communicates with both teams well, knows the game, and tries his best to stay organized on top of their busy schedule. "

0

Men's Tennis

Cole Sutton

Men's Tennis Assistant Coach

Loyola University (Maryland)

NCAA DI • Golden Valley | GVC

Positive Person And Cares About Each Player

Date: October 2, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"I really like Cole Sutton as our assistant coach. he's respectful to all players and a very positive person. he makes practices fun"

0

Coed Tennis

Cole Sutton

Women's and Men's Tennis Head Coach

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

Good Assistant Coach Motivational And Goal Driven

Date: October 2, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"coach Cole believes in you and wants you to succeed. Creates a good team atmosphere and makes sure you get better at least 1% every practice, hitting sesh, and match. "

0

Coed Tennis

Cole Sutton

Women's and Men's Tennis Head Coach

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

Caring Respectful And Understanding

Date: October 2, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"My daughter plays for coach Cole Sutton and says he cares and respects everyone on the team. "

0

Men's Tennis

Cole Sutton

Men's Tennis Assistant Coach

Loyola University (Maryland)

NCAA DI • Golden Valley | GVC

Dedicated To Improve Beyond The Court

Date: October 2, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"sutton is direct, believes in each one of his players, creates a great team culture, and is dedicated in improving beyond the court. "

0

Coed Tennis

Cole Sutton

Women's and Men's Tennis Head Coach

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

A Great Leader Should Be Head Coach

Date: October 2, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"coach Sutton is passionate about coaching, organized, knowledgeable, honest, and a great leader"

0

Men's Tennis

Cole Sutton

Men's Tennis Assistant Coach

Loyola University (Maryland)

NCAA DI • Golden Valley | GVC

Honest And Motivates His Player We All Like Him.

Date: October 2, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"Cole is honest and knowledgeable about the game. He would be a great head coach for this program and we all want that for him. "

0

Coed Tennis

Cole Sutton

Women's and Men's Tennis Head Coach

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

He Wants You To Do Well And That Pushes Everyone To Perform Better.

Date: October 2, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"I've never really heard anyone complain about Coach Cole. He tries his best to coach everyone on the team and he's pretty cool. He wants you to do well and that pushes everyone to perform better. "

0

Coed Tennis

Cole Sutton

Women's and Men's Tennis Head Coach

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

Coach Sutton Is Great, Motivational, And Believes In You.

Date: October 2, 2023

By Other

4.6

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

4.0

5.0

4.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"Coach Sutton is one of the best coaches I've been able to work with. He's honest, believes in you, very motivational, and very easy to get along with. "

0

Coed Tennis

Cole Sutton

Women's and Men's Tennis Head Coach

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

Cole Sutton Assistant Coach At Loyola University Maryland

Date: October 1, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"Cole Sutton is in his second year of coaching both the Mens and Womens Tennis Team at Loyola University Maryland."

0

Men's Tennis

Cole Sutton

Men's Tennis Assistant Coach

Loyola University (Maryland)

NCAA DI • Golden Valley | GVC

Very Fair And Knowledgeable As A Coach.

Date: October 1, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"Admirable how he can relate to players as a former college player."

0

Men's Tennis

Cole Sutton

Men's Tennis Assistant Coach

Loyola University (Maryland)

NCAA DI • Golden Valley | GVC

Very Organized And Understanding.

Date: October 1, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Believes In You Direct Knowledgeable Fair Motivational

"Very organized and calm. Cares about our performance."

0

Lacrosse

Dave Webster

Men's Lacrosse Head Coach/ Assitant athletic director

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

The Best Coach Around. D1 D2 Or D3.

Date: September 7, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Direct Creates A Great Team Culture Accessible Cool Intense

"Best Coach around. Loves the gane, loves the student athletes, loves his program. Has created a great culture at the school for both players and families. "

0

Men's Soccer

Brian Redding

Men's Soccer Head Coach

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

The Absolute Worst Coach Possible

Date: July 31, 2023

By Other

1.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

1.0

Tags

Cool Direct Intense Accessible Honest

"Horrible. The absolute worst person you could have coach your son."

0

Lacrosse

Dave Webster

Men's Lacrosse Head Coach/ Assitant athletic director

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

Greatest Coach I Have Ever Had

Date: May 3, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Direct Creates A Great Team Culture Accessible Cool Intense

"Webby was an amazing coach on and off the field. The culture that he has created at Dickinson will stand the test of time. He was a great leader of young men and instilled so many life lessons that I have taken into my career. He made me not only a better lacrosse player, but a better teammate, and most importantly a better person."

0

Lacrosse

Dave Webster

Men's Lacrosse Head Coach/ Assitant athletic director

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

Best Program In College Lacrosse

Date: April 26, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Direct Creates A Great Team Culture Accessible Cool Intense

"More than a coach. A mentor, an ambassador for the sport, a father-figure, a guidance giver, a leader of men."

0

Lacrosse

Dave Webster

Men's Lacrosse Head Coach/ Assitant athletic director

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

They Don’t Call It Webby’s Army For Nothing

Date: April 26, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Direct Creates A Great Team Culture Accessible Cool Intense

"The greatest coach I’ve ever had. That about sums it up. He’s built the greatest program in college lacrosse, I am proud to have played for him. "

0

Lacrosse

Dave Webster

Men's Lacrosse Head Coach/ Assitant athletic director

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

I Would Take A Bullet For Coach Webster

Date: April 26, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Direct Creates A Great Team Culture Accessible Cool Intense

"This man changed my life. I wouldn't be where I am today without him. A second father and the greatest role model you could ask for. "

0

Lacrosse

Dave Webster

Men's Lacrosse Head Coach/ Assitant athletic director

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

He’s The Greatest Man To Walk This Earth

Date: April 26, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Direct Creates A Great Team Culture Accessible Cool Intense

"Loved playing for him on and off the field"

0

Lacrosse

Dave Webster

Men's Lacrosse Head Coach/ Assitant athletic director

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

A Mentor And Coach For Life

Date: April 25, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Direct Creates A Great Team Culture Accessible Cool Intense

"Coach Webby is one of the greatest mentors a young man can ask for. I don’t believe any words I put in this box will ever serve his impact on the Dickinson community, players, parents and families a sliver of the justice it deserves. He is a great man who always puts his team first, has his players best interests front of mind, will tell you how it is and needs to be, keeps all of his players and parents on the same page, and never shys away from delivering hard conversations. I hope everyone has a coach like Webby in there life. He simply makes you a better person. "

0

Lacrosse

Dave Webster

Men's Lacrosse Head Coach/ Assitant athletic director

Dickinson College

NCAA DIII • Coastal Collegiate Sports Association Beach Volleyball | CCSA

He's The Man And Cares About His Players

Date: April 19, 2023

By Other

5.0

Overall

Caring

Motivational

Knowledgeable

Honest

5.0

Tags

Direct Creates A Great Team Culture Accessible Cool Intense

"Great coach with a great program"

0

Ratings

• Colleges

Dickinson College

• All Reviews

All Reviews

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags

Tags